Was truman justified in his decision

was truman justified in his decision On 11 april 1951, us president harry s truman relieved general of the army douglas macarthur of his commands after macarthur made public statements which contradicted the administration's policies macarthur was a popular hero of world war ii who was then the commander of united nations forces fighting in the korean war, and his relief remains a controversial topic in the field of civil.

What events are key to his decision i'm doing an essay on this topic and i wanted to know more information on the context and circumstances of the event so i can do some research at a library thank you 1 following was truman justified in dropping the atomic bombs. Did truman make the right decision by dropping the atomic bomb was the us in general (not just president truman) justified in its dropping of the atomic bomb was truman justified in dropping the atomic bombs. Name professor module date to what extent was truman’s decision to drop the atomic bombs on japan in world war ii justified a: plan of investigation before august 6 1945, atomic bombs had never been used in war, and no one had an idea of the magnitude of their destructive capability.

Was truman justified in his decision to drop the atomic bomb on august 6th, 1945, the united states dropped the first ever atomic weapon on hiroshima, japan 140,000 people lost their lives, most of which were civilians. In a 6 to 3 decision, the court ruled against truman in the majority decision, justice hugo black wrote, “in the framework of our constitution, the president's power to see that the laws are faithfully executed refutes the idea that he is to be a lawmaker. Truman, for his part, thought he was bringing the war to a swift close taken in its time, the decision was the right one as historian david mccullough has been known to say, “people living. Truman was right to drop the atom bomb one of the most controversial issues of the twentieth century is the decision by president truman to use the atomic bomb on hiroshima and nagasaki in doing so he may have saved millions of lives but he ushered in the start of the nuclear age that still casts its shadow.

Two other initiatives in the truman presidency demonstrate his application of kantian principles in the exercise of his office the first is the marshall plan, which was a strategy for rebuilding europe with us financial support (named after general george marshall, who was truman’s secretary of state. Hasegawa is no less provocative in assessing america's decision to employ atomic weapons truman was eager to drop the bomb, he writes, and was unwilling to explore alternatives for three reasons. President truman justified his reason to drop the bomb by stating that hiroshima was a 5ibid 6 knowledge of the intricate relationship of the japanese emperor to his people by his decision to drop the atomic bomb in 1945, president truman had as comprehensive an understanding of. Truman was right to use the bomb on japan harry s truman was characteristically terse and not particularly introspective about his decision to use the bomb but it is clear from his diary. Perhaps the most controversial decision of the koren war --and indeed the least popular presidential decision of all time--was president truman's relief of general douglas macarthur from his position as supreme allied commander in korea.

Best answer: yes it was justified,remember you are looking at the events from the safety of the 21st century,but let's look at the situation at the time,us troops had been fighting a long bloody war in europe (for the 2nd time) and despite that war coming to an end the war in the pacific looked like it. Philippine justice delfin jaranilla, member of the tokyo tribunal, wrote in his judgment: if a means is justified by an end, the use of the atomic bomb was justified for it brought japan to her knees and ended the horrible war on his way to potsdam, truman had re-examined the decision to use the bomb in the end, he made the decision to. The truman administration's decision to oppose the invasion of south korea by north korea in june, 1950 was made without congressional approval while there was a large gap between what harry truman said about civil rights and what he was able to do, his greatest accomplishment was in.

For truman, the choice whether or not to use the atomic bomb was the most difficult decision of his life first, an allied demand for an immediate unconditional surrender was made to the leadership in japan. The article provoked a response from president harry truman, who wrote in from the white house to emphasize his own role in the decision-making process the letter was printed in the front of the. Decision to drop the bomb in recent years historians and policy analysts have questioned president truman's decision to use the atomic bomb against japan for president truman, the decision was a clear-cut one. The decision to drop the bomb was not made by scientists or by the military, it was made by harry s truman and, he stated he weighed the american losses of an invasion against using the bomb as for a blockade, it wouldn't have done much to japan to break their will.

Was truman justified in his decision

was truman justified in his decision On 11 april 1951, us president harry s truman relieved general of the army douglas macarthur of his commands after macarthur made public statements which contradicted the administration's policies macarthur was a popular hero of world war ii who was then the commander of united nations forces fighting in the korean war, and his relief remains a controversial topic in the field of civil.

It wasn't till aug 10, 1945, one day after the atomic bombing of nagasaki and four days after hiroshima, that president truman made his first explicit decision about the bomb. Was president truman’s decision to drop the “bomb” on japan justified “the atomic bomb certainly is the most powerful of all weapons” -lyndon b johnson on august 6 and 9, 1945, president harry truman decided to drop 2 atomic bombs named little boy and fat man, both weighing in over 9,700 pounds, on the cities of hiroshima and. President truman's decision to drop the atomic bombs on hiroshima and nagasaki was justified even though churchill and many of truman's advisers believed the japanese were close to surrendering, they could not have been sure.

  • Michael walzer (juw) gives two arguments for why president truman’s decision to drop the atomic bomb on japan at the end of wwii was in fact the morally wrong decision his first argument rests on the claim that the standard justification is predicated on a false dilemma.
  • Best answer: yes he was justified in using the atomic bomb, and here is why: 1 a full-scale invasion to take over japan would have taken a lot longer than a couple of days it would have taken months, even years to accomplish that task 2 that fight to successfully take over japan would have cost.
  • His successor, president harry s truman, made the fateful decision to use the atomic bomb to end the war and ordered the attacks that would lead to japan's ultimate surrender looking back on the period, questions about this administration's responsibility for the carnage of this event exist.

Although in later decades there was considerable debate about whether the bombings were ethically justified, virtually all of america’s political and military leadership, as well as most of those involved in the atomic bomb project, believed at the time that truman’s decision was correct. Primary source document with questions (dbqs) “the decision to use the atomic bomb” (february 1947) by henry lewis stimson introduction the dropping of the atomic bombs on hiroshima (august 6, 1945) and nagasaki (august 9, 1945) remains among the. Get an answer for 'argue that president truman's decision to use atomic bombs against japan was justified' and find homework help for other world war ii questions at enotes.

was truman justified in his decision On 11 april 1951, us president harry s truman relieved general of the army douglas macarthur of his commands after macarthur made public statements which contradicted the administration's policies macarthur was a popular hero of world war ii who was then the commander of united nations forces fighting in the korean war, and his relief remains a controversial topic in the field of civil.
Was truman justified in his decision
Rated 5/5 based on 28 review

2018.